Three visitors, a missing brass nightingale and two clocks that disagree. Work through the records and decide who had the opportunity.
3 minutes★★★☆☆ 3/5 Author estimateNo printer or account needed
Watch. Pause. Make your deduction.The answer starts at 02:22. Pause before then if you want more thinking time.
Changing format pauses the film and keeps your place.
Full captions are included in the picture. English captions and a transcript are also available.
Original fictional mystery made with AI-assisted imagery, cinematic footage and narration; original synthesized score.
Read the full transcript — includes the answer
Spoilers follow. For the mystery first, watch the film above.
[00:00:00] [Printed Secret introduction.]
[00:00:03] Three visitors. A vanished nightingale. Two clocks that disagree. Can the records tell you who had the opportunity?
[00:00:11] The clockmaker had built a nightingale from brass. One evening, someone took it from his workshop.
[00:00:17] He saw it before he left. When he returned, the case was empty. The thief was one of these three visitors.
[00:00:24] The door record is complete and accurate. Nobody else entered. There was no other entrance, hidden person, accomplice, or delayed device. The theft happened during his absence.
[00:00:35] Earlier that evening, at exactly eleven by a correct clock, the wall clock showed ten fifty-six. The pocket watch showed eleven oh six.
[00:00:47] Both clocks ran steadily at the correct rate. Neither was adjusted after that check. Every reading belongs to the same evening.
[00:00:56] Mara arrived at ten fifty-eight on the wall clock, and left at eleven twelve on the pocket watch.
[00:01:04] Owen arrived at eleven twelve on the pocket watch, and left at eleven fourteen on the wall clock.
[00:01:12] Iris arrived at eleven oh eight on the wall clock, and left at eleven twenty-two on the pocket watch.
[00:01:20] When the clockmaker saw the nightingale and left, the wall clock read eleven oh four. The bird was still there at that moment.
[00:01:30] When he returned and found it missing, the pocket watch read eleven sixteen. The theft happened between those two inspections.
[00:01:40] Here is the attendant’s original record. Each arrival and departure preserves the reading from the clock used. The names and readings are reliable.
[00:01:52] You have the earlier clock check, the two inspections, and all three visits. Take your time. Every fact you need is on the screen.
[00:02:02] Who could have taken the nightingale? Give the visitor’s name and the interval on a correct clock. Explain why.
[00:02:10] [Complete evidence board. Pause to investigate. Music only.]
[00:02:22] It was Owen. At the reference check, the wall clock was four minutes slow; the pocket watch, six minutes fast.
[00:02:32] The bird was present at eleven oh eight, and missing at eleven ten, on a correct clock.
[00:02:42] Mara had already left. Iris had not arrived. Owen was in the workshop throughout those two minutes. Only he had the opportunity.
[00:02:54] For the full explanation and more mysteries, visit The Printed Secret.
Keep The Printed Secret close
Add the app to your home screen or desktop. Accounts, games and saves need an internet connection.
In Chrome or Edge, choose Install app in the browser menu. On iPhone or iPad, open the Share menu, then choose Add to Home Screen and Open as Web App if offered. Other browsers may offer Add to Home Screen or Add to Dock.
Help us improve the mystery.
May we collect optional website statistics? These help us see which pages people visit, approximate countries and which links they use. We do not record your email, game answers or access codes. Statistics stay on our server and expire after 90 days.
Optional statistics are off until you choose. You can change your choice here at any time. Read our privacy notice.